Do you want great food in the Upper West Side? This part of NYC has lots to try. You will find both fun and fine meals here. Are you ready to savor a nourishing bite? These top-rated places promise a meal to remember.
What are the Top Places to Eat in Upper West Side NYC?
Some of the most recommended places include:
- Jacob’s Pickles – Warm food from the South, with bold taste and house-made pickles
- Carmine’s – Large, rich meals with true Italo flair
- Elea – Fresh fish, Greek touch, cool mood
- Bustan – Rich spice, bold bites from the Med
- Café Lux – Fancy food with calm charm
- Maison Pickle – Big looks, big taste
Let’s explore each one in more detail below.
1. Elea
Elea brings the heart of Greece to the Upper West Side. The design is fresh and bright, with stone walls, soft light, and blue touches. It feels like a calm island corner in the middle of the city. It is one of the most relaxing places to eat in the Upper West Side if you’re looking for fresh seafood and fine wine.
Start with the spreads. You’ll get tzatziki, hummus, and spicy feta dip served with warm pita. The dips are thick, cold, and rich in flavor. The grilled octopus is tender and smokey, plated with fava beans and onions. Seafood is the star. The whole branzino comes crisp and buttery, with lemon and herbs. The lobster pasta is silky, with light tomato sauce and garlic that doesn’t overpower.
Pair your meal with a glass of Assyrtiko; a white wine from Greece that cuts the olive oil just right. The servers know their wine list and are happy to help you pick. The baklava at Elea is not too sweet. It’s flaky, with crushed nuts and just enough honey.
Elea is ideal for birthdays, date nights, or any time you need a little sunshine in your soul. If you’re listing the best places to eat in Upper West Side NYC with a modern twist, this spot belongs near the top. Locals and visitors alike agree it’s one of the good places to eat in the Upper West Side.
2. Bustan
Bustan feels alive. It’s full of color, heat, and scent. The oven is open and glowing, with flames dancing as the chefs slide in flatbreads and meats. Every bite here feels warm, bold, and deep.
Start with the meze. The hummus is creamy, the labneh tart, and the eggplant dip rich and smokey. These come with fresh pita, baked in-house. Try the duck shawarma flatbread. It is thin, crisp, and filled with spice and tender meat. The main dishes are hearty. The lamb kebab comes with rice, sumac onions, and grilled veggies. The Moroccan tagine is soft, sweet, and full of deep spice.
The drinks are smart. Try the Za’atar Martini. It blends gin with herbs and lemon. You’ll remember it. The space is fun. You’ll see tiles, wood, candles, and hanging lanterns. If the weather is good, the garden opens out back. It’s quiet, green, and perfect for deep talks or date nights. Every bite feels crafted. Every plate has history. You won’t leave hungry and you’ll likely plan your next visit before dessert ends.
3. Jacob’s Pickles
The smell of butter and warm biscuits hits you at the door. The wood tables and soft lights create a cozy setting. Jacob’s has a full vibe and is easily one of the best places to eat on the Upper West Side for comfort food lovers. Their Southern menu is deep and bold. You get food that hugs you. You can try soft hot buns with fried bird on top. It may drip with sweet glaze or thick meat sauce. Their pan-baked mac oozes with cheese and crunch. Pickles? Yes, hot, sour, crisp. You may want ten.
The drink menu adds more charm. Try the Pickleback. It blends their brine with dark booze. It may sound odd, but it’s smooth and bold.
Don’t miss the jars of pickles. You can try sour cukes or hot veg. If you want a smooth ride there, think ahead. You can use rental cars in New York to skip slow subways and plan your trip better. If you’re searching for places to eat in the Upper West Side that feel cozy but exciting, this one hits the mark.
4. Café Luxembourg
Café Luxembourg brings old Paris into modern New York. The lights are low, the tiles shine, and mirrors reflect the soft glow. It’s elegant, but never cold.
The menu is French, but friendly. You’ll find steak frites, moules marinières, and duck confit that fall off the bone. The burger here is also worth your time, and it is served with crispy fries and grainy mustard on the side. Brunch is a favorite. The croque madame comes hot with melted cheese, ham, and a runny egg on top. The eggs Benedict sit on toasted brioche, drizzled in rich hollandaise.
The drinks menu is full of smart picks. A kir royale or Sancerre pairs perfectly with most plates. For dessert, try the chocolate mousse. It is light, rich, and served cold in a silver bowl.
Service is polished. Staff are kind, fast, and never hover. It’s a spot for long talks, quiet romance, or a meal before Lincoln Center. Café Luxembourg isn’t loud or trendy. It’s steady, classy, and always delivers. You come once, then keep coming back.
5. Carmine’s
Carmine’s feels like home. It smells like baked cheese and red sauce. You’ll hear big laughs and the joy is palpable. Each dish feeds 4 people or more. Try the bird parm. It’s crisp, thin, and rich with red sauce and soft cheese. Or pick the fish pasta. It’s full of clams, shrimp, and mussels in white sauce.
The space feels old and sweet. You’ll see red seats, old pics, and soft glow. Each plate comes big, each bite full. If the list feels long, the staff can help you pick.Carmine’s easily earns its place on any list of the best places to eat in Upper West Side NYC.
Coming for a big day? Rent a Range Rover — you’ll hold your crew with ease and dine like stars. End with the cold cream treat. It’s soft, sweet, and great to share.
6. Maison Pickle
Maison Pickle sits right on Broadway and pulls you in the second you walk past. Bright neon signs glow at the windows. Soft music plays inside. The air smells like butter and garlic. It feels rich and loud in the best way.
The space is bold. There are black-and-white floors, velvet booths, and glowing globe lights. Every table has someone snapping a photo. That’s because the food looks huge and beautiful. Even the menu feels fun.
Start with the pull-apart garlic bread. It comes hot in a skillet, soaked in garlic butter, and topped with cheese and herbs. Then there’s the Matzoh Ball French Onion Soup, which is a mix of comfort and classic. The Shrimp Scampi Mac & Cheese is creamy, rich, and served in a deep, bubbling bowl.
Their French dip sandwiches are famous. Picture sliced roast beef, melted gruyère, onions, and horseradish sauce, all packed in a crusty baguette. A small pitcher of hot jus comes on the side, ready for dipping. It’s hot, soft, crunchy, and salty in every bite.
Don’t skip the fried chicken. You can get it with hot honey or stacked on waffles. It’s crispy on the outside, juicy inside, and always piping hot. If you’re coming for brunch, the challah French toast is thick, sweet, and loaded with berries or whipped cream. It’s both breakfast and dessert.
©2025 The Dedicated House. All rights reserved. No part of this blog post may be used or reproduced without the written consent of the copyright owner.
Click the links below for any posts you have missed:
Reduce Hot Water Bills: Size Your System Properly
Using Junk Removal to Simplify Life in Multi-Unit Homes
Why Septic Pumping in Mishawaka Is a Must for Homeowners
Why Do You Need a Trusted HVAC Company in Covington?
Emergency HVAC Repair and Installation across South Florida
Types of Relief Loans You Can Apply for if You Are a Victim of the Eaton Fire
I’d love for you to join my email list! You’ll receive a notification straight to your inbox which will include links to my latest home project posts! Simply enter your address below.
Thanks for stopping by! Have a wonderful day/night depending on where you are in the world! Go with God and remember to be kind to one another!
Toodles,
[…] Top Places to Eat in Upper West Side NYC […]